Reviewer Guidelines

The peer-review process is a fundamental cornerstone in maintaining the scientific quality and integrity of Jurnal Geologi dan Pertambangan (JGP). We deeply appreciate the dedication and contributions of our peer reviewers.

Principles of Peer Review

Confidentiality & Ethics

Submitted manuscripts must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not share, discuss, or use any part of the text without prior written permission from the editors.

Conflict of Interest

Reviewers should decline invitations if any financial, collaborative, or personal conflicts of interest exist with the authors or connected institutions.

Objectivity & Constructiveness

Reviews should be conducted objectively and free of personal criticism. Provide constructive feedback supported by clear scientific arguments to help authors improve their work.

Timeliness

Reviewers are requested to respond promptly and submit evaluations within the agreed period. If an extension is required, please notify the editorial team immediately.

Recommendation Options: Accept Submission | Revisions Required | Resubmit for Review | Decline Submission